All submissions will first be pre-screened by a member of the Alliance team. The pre-screen will ensure that all required components of the submissions are included before being sent to a community reviewer. Proposals that are missing content will be returned to the submitter for completion and will be sent to reviewers once the proposal is complete. Each complete submission will be reviewed by two community reviewers and will undergo an open review process, which means that the identities of both submitters and reviewers will be known to each other and disclosed at the start of the process. The decision to engage an open-review process is part of an effort to bring more transparency and equity to this submission process. Reviewers will be asked to provide feedback to authors based upon the following:
Submission Essentials
Presentation Overview
Reviewer Comments to Submitter
In an effort to continue to provide support to our community of stakeholders, we ask that you offer written feedback to the submitter/s, who will be able to see your comments and your name when receiving your written assessment. Please ensure that you offer some feedback on the following: Structure of the proposal; Strength of the proposal’s content; Potential engagement with the audience; Strategies to accomplish desired learning outcomes; Quality of the idea and/or argument.